What Is The Difference Between Deferred Compensation Plans And 401(k)s?
Feb 06, 2023 By Kelly Walker

If you're considering setting up a retirement savings plan for yourself or your business, you may have heard of deferred compensation plans and 401(k)s. But what is the difference between these two savings plans, and which one is right for you?

Let's break down the key differences between the two in this blog post!

What is a Deferred Compensation Plan?

A deferred compensation plan is an employer-sponsored retirement savings plan in which employees set aside a portion of their paychecks before taxes are taken out. This money is then invested in stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and other investments until it’s time to withdraw from the account at retirement age.

The main benefit of a deferred compensation plan is that money is invested before taxes are taken out. There are potentially more significant returns than other retirement accounts, such as IRAs and 401(k)s.

Deferred Compensation Plans: Pros And Cons

These plans generally allow employees to defer part of their salary until retirement and pay taxes when the money is disbursed instead of earned. The most considerable benefit is that the employee will receive a more significant sum of money in the future since the taxes withheld at that time may be lower than current tax rates.

Additionally, the earning potential over this time can multiply due to investments made by either the employer or employee. On the other hand, deferred compensation plans carry a significant risk since any market downturn could take away a substantial portion of the funds available upon retirement.

Similarly, changes in public policy and personal financial circumstances may mean that individuals cannot access their money when initially planned. When considering a deferred compensation plan, weighing the pros and cons is essential for making an informed financial decision.

What Is a 401(K)?

A 401(k) is another employer-sponsored retirement savings plan in which employees can save pre-tax dollars for retirement. Contributions to a 401(k) are made with after-tax dollars, meaning they’re not subject to income tax when withdrawn at retirement age.

The main benefit of a 401(k) is that employers match contributions up to certain limits. Employees can receive extra money toward their retirement without any additional effort. Additionally, some employers offer Roth 401(k)'s with after-tax contributions that grow tax-free over time.

401(K) Plans: Pros And Cons

Employers offer 401(K) Plans to help employees save a portion of their earnings for retirement. Many people find them attractive because the money can be invested and grows with time, allowing it to compound in value over many years. As such, 401(K) Plans offer the potential for solid long-term gains in the fund balance.

However, participants should note that those funds are not accessible until retirement. Additionally, contributions to the plan are subject to taxes, so anyone investing in one should understand how that impacts their financial situation today and in retirement.

Finally, participants need to recognize that there is some risk involved with any investment, and 401(K) plans are no exception.

Key Differences Between Deferred Compensation Plans And 401(k)?

Everyone wants to maximize their savings and access funds in the future. Deferred compensation plans and 401(k)s offer various options for people to save money, but understanding their fundamental differences is crucial.

While both use pre-tax dollars and investments to grow assets, a deferred compensation plan allows a person to set aside an agreed-upon percentage of income or a lump sum payment that can be accessed until established vesting periods have elapsed.

Furthermore, with deferred compensation plans, there are usually more generous contributions than traditional retirement plans, as earnings are not taxed. In contrast, 401(k)s typically require annual contributions from employees at maximum limits, and all incomes within the account are taxed when withdrawn.

Understanding the differences between these two types of savings accounts is helpful so that savers can make informed decisions on which option best suits their short and long-term personal financial needs.

Why Is Deferred Compensation Preferable To A 401(K)?

Deferred compensation, such as bonus pay and stock options, is a better retirement savings option than a 401(k). Unlike 401(k) plans, with deferred compensation, there are no monthly or annual contribution limits. This means you can save more money for your retirement by taking advantage of the total size of qualifying bonuses, incentive pay, or other forms of employer-based financial reward.

Beyond that, many companies offer to match employee contributions beyond the limits of standard 401(k) plans. This means even more money saved for later in life. Plus, with deferred compensation, there is greater flexibility in accessing the funds compared to strict regulations on 401(k) withdrawals.

In short, deferred compensation offers many advantages not found with typical 401(k) plans when it comes to helping you save for your future retirement goals.

Can You Have a Deferred Compensation Plan and a 401(k) Plan simultaneously?

Yes, you can have both plans at the same time.

It can be confusing to manage both of these tools simultaneously, but the reality is that they are complementary; you can have both at times and can work together to provide more robust retirement security.

When Is It Possible to Withdraw From a Deferred Compensation Plan?

Withdrawing from a deferred compensation plan can be an essential financial step. This type of plan allows you to postpone your salary payment. As such, most deferred compensation plans have specific rules about when withdrawals are permitted.

Generally, it is possible to withdraw funds as soon as you reach retirement age or upon the termination of employment. After reaching this milestone, you will still need to wait a certain period before receiving the funds. This waiting period depends on the terms and conditions established in your particular deferral agreement.

It is essential to remember that withdrawals are heavily taxed, so careful planning is necessary to ensure a successful retirement.

Final Takeaway

Individuals looking to save for the future can benefit significantly from deferred compensation plans and 401(k). However, each type of plan has distinct advantages and disadvantages that must be carefully considered when deciding which option is best for your specific needs.

Understanding the differences will go a long way toward helping you make an informed decision about how best to save for your future so you can enjoy your golden years worry-free!